Part 2: Crafting Stability and Growth - A Deep Dive into Historical Sector Performance and How to Optimize Asset Allocation

Part 2: Crafting Stability and Growth – A Deep Dive into Historical Sector Performance and How to Optimize Asset Allocation

Understanding asset allocation is essential in portfolio construction, impacting not just volatility but also long-term returns. For those beginning their investment journey, grasping this concept is the first step toward building a successful portfolio.

A Well-Rounded Portfolio

An effective portfolio typically includes a mix of yield, value, and growth stocks, complemented by cash, bonds, and non-correlated assets. Consider a portfolio with a target of a 4% yield and 10% long-term returns, displaying substantially less volatility than the S&P 500, and less susceptible to downturns in bear markets. Such a portfolio will include a mix of ETFs, Hedges (short and log-term bonds, managed futures, cash) and individual stocks, typically in a 33/33/33 ratio depending how aggressive you want to be on growth and total returns. The higher the allocation on ETFs and individual stocks, the higher the volatility of the portfolio. A portfolio that balances index funds, cash and bonds, and individual blue-chips is designed to reduce volatility, particularly during bear markets. Comparing it to a traditional 60/40 retirement portfolio, this approach offers higher yield and safer withdrawal rates, backed by analysts’ expectations and historical performance data. For example the Road To $1 Million portfolio is currently (since just started) highly focused on income growth with a high % exposure to individual stocks and ETFs, and lower exposure to hedges such as long and short term bonds. However, keep in mind that weekly allocations in our example portfolio will allow to adjust exposure depending on market dynamics.

Historical Performance Insights

  • Tobacco Sector: During the tech crash (January 2000 to December 2002), tobacco companies like Altria (MO) and British American Tobacco (BTI) bucked the trend. For instance, MO saw a 106% increase in 2000, while the S&P dropped by 9%. Similarly, during the Great Recession (October 2007 to February 2009), defensive blue-chips like MO and BTI generally fell less than the broader market.
  • Energy and Midstream: In 2022, the energy sector, with companies like Enbridge (ENB) and Enterprise Products Partners (EPD), performed exceptionally, demonstrating their value as stabilizing elements in a portfolio. During the tech crash, midstream companies like EPD and ENB experienced significant growth, with EPD rising 87% in 2000, outperforming the S&P.
  • REITs: Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) like Realty Income (O) and Federal Realty (FRT) also showed resilience. During the tech crash, O and FRT had minimal declines and even posted gains, contrasting with the S&P 500’s decline. However, during the Great Recession, the performance of REITs was more aligned with the broader market downturn.

Bonds and Cash in Portfolio Stability

Bonds and cash have historically played a crucial role in stabilizing portfolios during market downturns. For example, during the tech crash and the Great Recession, treasuries and bonds provided a hedge against the declining stock market, often delivering positive returns when equities were falling.

StrategyETFTickerMorningstar RatingExpense Ratio
0-3 Month T-Bills (CASH)iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETFSGOVSilver0.03%
Floating Rate Short Term Treasuries (CASH)WisdomTree Floating Rate Treasury FundUSFR3 Star Silver0.15%
Investment Grade BondsSchwab US Aggregate Bond ETFSCHZ3 Star Silver0.04%
7-10 Year TreasuriesiShares 7-10 Year Treasury Bond ETFIEF4 Star Bronze0.15%
Long-Duration US TreasuriesVanguard Long-Term Treasury ETFVGLT4 Star Gold0.04%
20-30 Year US TreasuriesVanguard Extended Duration Trs ETFEDV2 Star Gold0.06%
Longest Duration US TreasuriesPIMCO 25+ Year Zero Coupon US Trs ETFZROZ1 Star Bronze0.15%

Choosing the Right ETFs

When selecting ETFs, consider those covering various strategies:

StrategyETFTickerMorningstar RatingExpense Ratio
Dividend GrowthSchwab US Dividend ETFSCHD5 Star-Silver0.06%
High-YieldVanguard High-Yield ETFVYM4 Star-Silver0.06%
REITsVanguard REIT ETFVNQ3 Star-Gold0.12%
ValueVanguard Value ETFVTV5 Star-Gold0.04%
QualityProShares S&P 500 Dividend AristocratsNOBL5 Star-Neutral0.35%
All Global StocksVanguard Total World Stock ETFVT3 Star-Gold0.07%
Dividend GrowthVanguard Dividend Appreciation ETFVIG4 Star-Gold0.06%
S&P 500Vanguard S&P 500VOO5 Star-Gold0.03%
All US StocksVanguard Total Stock MarketVTI4 Star-Gold0.03%
GrowthNasdaq 100QQQM5 Star-Neutral0.15%
GrowthVanguard Russell 1000 GrowthVONG5 Star-Gold0.08%

The Critical Role of Sector Allocation in Diversifying Your Portfolio

A key element often overlooked in portfolio construction is sector allocation. A well-diversified portfolio spreads investments across various industry sectors, ensuring that different components perform under varying economic conditions. This approach is crucial because not all sectors react the same way to market changes. For instance, while tech stocks might surge in a booming economy, consumer staples or utilities might hold steadier during downturns. By diversifying across sectors, you always have a segment of your portfolio positioned to potentially thrive. This not only helps in mitigating risk but also capitalizes on the strengths of different sectors, ensuring that there’s always a component in your portfolio that works, regardless of the market’s overall direction. In essence, effective sector allocation is about balancing risk and opportunity, providing a more stable and resilient investment journey.

In the future articles of our series, we will focus more in detail into the intricacies of sector performance during critical historical periods, providing practical insights for a well-rounded investment strategy.

The Importance of Stress Testing

Beyond historical performance, stress testing your portfolio for future conditions is vital. Tools like Monte Carlo simulations help envision your portfolio’s behavior under various future economic scenarios, ensuring its robustness.

Conclusion: Building Confidence in Your Investment Journey

In summary, for those venturing into portfolio construction, understanding asset allocation is key. By drawing lessons from historical trends, evaluating asset correlations, and choosing a mix of ETFs, stocks, and bonds, you can create a portfolio that aligns with your financial goals. This approach is not just about wealth accumulation but building it with confidence and stability. Remember, a well-planned portfolio is your ally in navigating the complexities of the investment world, bringing you closer to financial peace of mind.

Road To $1 Million

Start Date: 04/17/2023

As of 07/12/2024:

  • Portfolio Value: $40,236
  • Left to reach $1M: $959,764

Share and Earn

If you’ve enjoyed reading an article on and feel inspired to share it with your friends or on your own blog, we’d love to hear about it! As a token of our appreciation for spreading the word, you could be selected to receive a $5 or $10 gift card. To participate in this offer, simply ensure you’re a Free Registered User on and let us know when you’ve shared our content. It’s our little way of saying thank you for being part of our community and helping others discover the value we offer.


TheFrugalFella Most Read

Meal Delivery Services – Discount Codes Read More…

TheFrugalFella Portfolio

Road To $1 Million Investment Portfolio Read More….

Discover the No-Cost Credit Card Secret: Up to $200 in Free Monthly Gift Cards

The Hidden Secret of this No-Fee Credit Card: $150-$200 in Free Monthly Gift Cards! Read More…

Featured Frugal Posts

Save $1.6/gallon on GAS with our Exclusive Upside Promo Codes! Read More…

How to Get the Peloton App+ for Half Price, $12.99/month Instead of $24/month

How to Get the Peloton App+ for Half Price, $12.99/month Instead of $24/month Read More….

HelloFresh and GreenChef coupon codes

Revolutionize Your Grocery Shopping: Slash Your Bills with HelloFresh, GreenChef, and EveryPlate – Get Free Food! Read More…

TopCashBack - Transform your spending into earnings

Transform Your Spending into Earnings with TopCashback! Read More…

Ember Fund: A Fun Way to Earn Free Bitcoin

Ember Fund: A Fun Way to Earn Free Bitcoin Read More…

$200 intro bonus and $1500/year in savings with the Amex Blue Cash Everyday card

$200 Welcome Bonus and $1500/year in savings with the AMEX Blue Cash Everyday! Read more…

Latest Comments

  1. thefrugalfella
  2. Richard Malias

Follow Us

About Us

Meet — Your savvy guide to smarter finances. We’re here to help you navigate the essentials of frugal living, dive into investment basics, and explore the potential of side hustles and passive income. Our practical tips are perfect for family budgeting, while our focus on tech’s role in finance offers a path to financial independence. Join us and turn financial wisdom into everyday reality.